🎁 Get the FREE AI Skills Starter Guide β€” Subscribe β†’
BytesAgainBytesAgain

← Back to Articles

Scrap.io vs Apify for Google Maps Leads: Sync MCP vs Polling (2026)

Scrap.io vs Apify for Google Maps Leads: Sync MCP vs Polling (2026)

By BytesAgain Team Β· Published November 20, 2026 Β·

Google Maps is the largest free business database on earth, and every lead-gen agent eventually wants a piece of it. Two tools come up again and again: Apify's Google Maps scrapers and Scrap.io. They overlap on the data β€” business names, addresses, phones, websites, ratings β€” but they behave very differently inside an AI agent.

The difference is not cosmetic. One makes your agent wait on a dataset. The other answers inside the same tool call. If you are wiring Google Maps into Claude, ChatGPT, or your own agent loop, that difference decides whether your workflow feels instant or feels like a batch job.

The real difference: polling vs synchronous results

Apify's model is an asynchronous actor run. You start a run with an input payload, the actor crawls Google Maps, writes results into a dataset, and finishes minutes later. Your agent β€” or your script β€” then polls GET /v2/datasets/{id}/items until rows appear. For a typical local search this is a one-to-five minute window of polling, retries, and "is it done yet?" logic.

That model is fine for scheduled batch jobs. It is awkward for conversation. When a user asks "find me 40 dentists in Austin with an email," a two-minute poll loop breaks the flow, and many agent frameworks simply time out before the dataset is ready.

Scrap.io flipped the model. Its MCP server lives at one address, scrap.io/mcp, and hands results straight back into the agent's context in the same call. Search, filter, export β€” one request in, structured JSON out, no dataset ID, no polling, no second round trip. The same request works through their REST API, JSON in and JSON out.

For an agent, that is the whole ballgame: one tool call instead of three.

Side by side

Apify (Google Maps actors) Scrap.io
Interaction model Async run + dataset polling (1–5 min) Synchronous MCP + REST, one call
Agent integration Actor API, needs polling logic Native MCP server, OAuth, works with Claude/ChatGPT/Gemini
Coverage Actor-dependent, per-search crawl 225M+ businesses indexed, 195 countries
Emails Available via actors/add-ons, extra cost Included, with social profiles and phone types
Counting a market Costs a run Free counts through MCP and the UI
Filtering After extraction Before extraction (email present, rating, no website, etc.)
Pricing shape Per 1,000 places, from ~$4 down to $1.50 on higher plans $49/month for 10,000 credits, free trial with 100 leads
Best fit Scheduled batch jobs, custom actor chains Conversational agents, on-demand lookups

Where Apify still wins

Be honest about this: Apify is not a bad tool, and it is not going away.

  • Pay-per-result pricing with no subscription suits one-off jobs. If you need 500 places once, $2 and no commitment is hard to beat.
  • Actor ecosystem. Apify has thousands of actors for sites that are not Google Maps. If your pipeline already starts there, adding a Maps actor is trivial.
  • Full run history and storage. Datasets persist, which matters for audit trails and reruns.
  • Custom crawling. If you need a field or a site no managed product covers, you can write your own actor.

If your workflow is "run nightly, write to a warehouse," Apify is a perfectly sane choice.

Where Scrap.io wins for agents

The moment the user is waiting, synchronous behavior wins.

  1. No polling code. No run IDs, no retry loops, no timeouts that fire while the dataset is still filling.
  2. Free market sizing. You can ask "how many restaurants in the US have an email?" and get a real number for zero credits. That single feature kills a lot of wasted spend β€” you size the market before you buy it.
  3. Filters before billing. Credits are only spent on leads that match your criteria. No exporting 10,000 rows to delete 8,000.
  4. More contact data. Emails, social profiles, and phone types (mobile vs landline) come back with the business record β€” the stuff the official Google Places API does not give you at any price.
  5. One endpoint, every client. The same scrap.io/mcp address works in Claude, ChatGPT's developer mode, Gemini, or any MCP client.

A caveat worth repeating from third-party reviews: a large share of the emails are generic inboxes (info@, contact@) rather than named decision-makers, and credits do not roll over month to month. Budget accordingly.

What it costs

For 10,000 leads:

  • Apify: roughly $40 at the standard $4 per 1,000 places rate, less on higher plans ($3 on Starter, $2 on Scale, $1.50 on Business).
  • Scrap.io: $49/month for 10,000 credits, including emails and social profiles, with a free trial of 100 leads.

At low volume the two are close. The break-even shifts as enrichment add-ons stack up on the Apify side, or once you factor in the engineering time spent writing and maintaining polling logic.

Wiring it into an agent

Scrap.io MCP β€” add a custom connector pointing at scrap.io/mcp and authorize via OAuth. In Claude: Settings β†’ Connectors β†’ Add custom connector. In ChatGPT: Settings β†’ Apps β†’ Developer Mode β†’ Create app. No API key juggling, no polling.

Scrap.io REST β€” the same request shape, for pipelines:

# Base URL: https://scrap.io/api/v1/  (Bearer token auth, see docs.scrap.io for endpoints)
curl -G "https://scrap.io/api/v1/<endpoint>" \
  -H "Authorization: Bearer $SCRAPIO_KEY" \
  --data-urlencode "query=dentists" \
  --data-urlencode "location=Austin, TX"

Results come back in the response body β€” JSON in, JSON out, no run ID to poll.

Apify β€” start the actor, then poll:

curl -X POST "https://api.apify.com/v2/acts/compass~crawler-google-places/runs?token=$APIFY_TOKEN" \
  -d '{"searchStringsArray":["dentists"],"locationQuery":"Austin, TX","maxCrawledPlacesPerSearch":50}'
# wait 1-5 minutes, then:
curl "https://api.apify.com/v2/datasets/$DATASET_ID/items?token=$APIFY_TOKEN"

Three calls, a wait, and a retry policy. Workable β€” just not conversational.

Verdict

  • Choose Apify when the job is scheduled, batchy, and you already live in the actor ecosystem.
  • Choose Scrap.io when the agent is talking to a human, when the answer needs to come back now, and when free counts plus pre-extraction filters save real money.

Both skills are listed on BytesAgain: Scrap.io Google Maps and the Apify Google Maps scraper. If you are building a lead-gen agent, start with the synchronous one and drop to Apify only when you actually need an async batch run.

FAQ

Does Scrap.io work without an account? Yes for counting. The free Maps Census MCP at scrap.io/census/mcp answers "how many businesses match this target" with no signup. Full contact exports need a paid plan.

Is the REST API really synchronous? Yes. The request returns the dataset in the response body. There is no run ID to poll.

Can my agent use both? Yes, and that is a reasonable design: Scrap.io for interactive lookups, Apify actors for scheduled bulk crawls.

Which is cheaper for a one-off 500-lead pull? Apify, at roughly $2 with no subscription. For recurring monthly pulls, the Scrap.io flat credit bucket usually wins once email enrichment is included.

Discover AI agent skills curated for your workflow

Browse All Skills β†’
Scrap.io vs Apify for Google Maps Leads: Sync MCP vs Polling (2026) | BytesAgain