Multi-Agent Trading Debate
by @w491623834-oss
Multi-agent trading debate framework for collective market decision-making. Use when a trading signal is detected or a position decision is needed. Triggers...
clawhub install multi-agent-trading-debate📖 About This Skill
name: multi-agent-trading-debate description: "Multi-agent trading debate framework for collective market decision-making. Use when a trading signal is detected or a position decision is needed. Triggers on: (1) Cron-triggered decision windows every 8 hours, (2) Significant price movements more than 5pct deviation from entry, (3) Manual request for team analysis, (4) Position review before execution. The debate follows a structured flow: regime detection, analyst reports, bull/bear arguments, judge verdict, execution or hold."
Multi-Agent Trading Debate
A structured multi-agent debate system for financial market decisions. Agents represent distinct roles: regime detection, technical analysis, on-chain data, sentiment, bull perspective, bear perspective, and final judgment.
Workflow
Signal Detected
↓
Regime Detection (trend/range/volatility)
↓
Analysts Report (technical + onchain + sentiment)
↓
Bull/Bear Arguments (independent positions)
↓
Trading Judge Verdict (confidence + position size)
↓
Execution → Prediction Log → Reflection
Quick Start
1. Send debate batch to Feishu trading group 2. Wait for analyst reports (timeout: 25 minutes) 3. Collect all responses 4. Synthesize verdict with confidence score 5. Execute if signal confirmed, otherwise hold
Debate Message Format
📊 【批次 #[YYYYMMDD-NNN] 自动辩论触发】🔍 Regime: [REGIME_RESULT]
当前持仓：[DIRECTION] [SIZE] @ [ENTRY] | 当前：[PRICE]
浮亏：-[AMOUNT] USDT
请各位分析师给出独立判断：
technical-analyst: K线形态分析
onchain-analyst: 链上大户动向
sentiment-analyst: 市场情绪短期
trading-bull: 看多理由（具体点位）
trading-bear: 看空理由（具体点位） @trading-judge 最终裁决，截止 [TIME]
Judge Verdict Template
📋 【交易裁决 #YYYYMMDD-NNN】Regime: [REGIME]
Confidence: [0-100]%
Signal: [BUY/SELL/HOLD]
Position: [SIZE] @ [PRICE]
Bull case: [summary]
Bear case: [summary]
Decision: [ACTION] [REASON]
Risk: [RISK_LEVEL]
Next review: [TIME]
Position Sizing
| Confidence | Max Position | Stop Loss | |-----------|-------------|-----------| | >80% | 100% | Tight (1.5%) | | 60-80% | 75% | Standard (3%) | | 40-60% | 50% | Wide (5%) | | <40% | 25% or hold | No entry |
Regime Detection Rules
| Regime | Description | Preferred Strategy | |--------|-------------|-------------------| | TRENDING | ADX > 25, clear direction | Momentum follow | | RANGING | ADX < 20, no clear trend | Mean reversion | | VOLATILE | High variance, uncertain | Reduced size, wider SL |
Prediction Log Entry
After each decision, record in predictions.jsonl:
{"timestamp":"ISO8601","regime":"TRENDING","signal":"HOLD","confidence":62,"reason":"No clear entry, ranging market","actual_outcome":"pending","pnl":0}
Key Files
regime/detector.py (ADX + trend analysis)risk/position_sizer.py (Kelly + risk budget)data/predictions.jsonldata/tca_log.jsonlWhen to Trigger
✅ Trigger debate:
🚫 Skip debate (hold current position):
💡 Examples
1. Send debate batch to Feishu trading group 2. Wait for analyst reports (timeout: 25 minutes) 3. Collect all responses 4. Synthesize verdict with confidence score 5. Execute if signal confirmed, otherwise hold